Court: Blocking in car made traffic stop illegal
Nov 9, 2013
By NIGEL DUARA
Of the Associated Press
PORTLAND — Traffic stops hold a unique place in Oregon law. They are, technically, “temporary seizures” that allow police to investigate a violation, identify a driver and issue a citation.
At that point, the stop is over. But what if the driver doesn't leave?
And what if he can't because the officer's car is in the way?
A decision by the Oregon Court of Appeals last week says the answer is, well, complicated.
The case in question involves a police officer in Marion County who pulled over a driver he recognized from a couple of previous high-speed chases, one of which ended in a struggle with police.
The officer parked behind the car, a Buick driven by Myles Peterson, and blocked him in. He proceeded to get Peterson's car registration, cited him for running a red light and told him he could leave.
But the officer was still parked behind the Buick, blocking it in. Then, he started to chat with Peterson and realized that the registration Peterson showed him was for an Acura, not a Buick.
The officer started a search and found a Visine bottle filled with heroin. A jury used that evidence to convict Peterson of the drug charge.
The appeals court found that, from the moment the officer told Peterson he could leave, the search was over. And by blocking him in, he created an “unlawful extension,” Judge Timothy Sercombe wrote in the ruling.
“You told him he was free to go, but he wasn't actually able to leave at that point, was he?” Peterson's attorney asked the officer during a hearing that was quoted in the ruling.
“If (Peterson) had asked me to move my patrol car at that point, I would have moved my patrol car and he would have been on his way,” the officer replied.
“But without asking you, he couldn't have left, isn't that right?” the attorney said.
Such stops have precedence, and the courts haven't been kind to law enforcement.
In one case, an Oregon State Police trooper told a group of men they could leave but leaned on the driver's side door, asked them if they were transporting contraband and asked to search the car. The court said that's illegal.
Prosecutors said that Peterson should have just asked the officer to move his car.
“We reject that argument because the obligation to unambiguously end traffic stops does not fall on citizens,” Sercombe ruled, “it falls on law enforcement officials.”
The court's decision sends the case back to Marion County Circuit Court Judge Albin W. Norblad, with orders that the seized heroin evidence be suppressed.
Reach reporter Nigel Duara on Twitter at http://www.twitter.com/nigelduara
Only News-Register subscribers can access this premium content.
To subscribe, click here. Daily, weekly, monthly and annual subscriptions available; Starting at just $2.
Already an online subscriber, please sign in:
• Mac voters due costly new ballots (2671)
• Murder weighs heavy on Dornon family (2409)
• Wildcats sink Pirates' aerial attack (2087)
• That winning feeling (1981)
• Emerging force (1376)